Suzanne Vega

Message Boards

- 9OOD - First Impressions -

Please send your replies to VegaNet@AOL.COM

Subj: Lyrics of Desire
Date: 96-07-09 21:56:28 EDT
From: arel@pc.jaring.my (Khairyl Yassin)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@law.emory.edu

Dear Eric and all Webmates,

Thanks a million Eric (and Suzanne), for the sneak preview of the lyrics. It's a great privilege of being on Undertow, or a frequent Suzanne website visitor. The lyrics are *all* wonderful. I was so excited when you announced that the lyrics were now available, I "ran" (borrowing your word, U212) to the homepage and printed out every single song.

Birth-day (Love Made Real), a would-be birth labor anthem, stands out, as well as the erotic Stockings. I also love My Favorite Plum and World Before Columbus. The lyrics seem to be a departure from her previous works. They feel more immediate, warmer and even child-like at times. There is a very direct quality to these lyrics, somehow they feel like they have not gone through the rigorous "sculpting and resculpting" process that I imagine Suzanne has always done. One word comes to mind: motherhood. It's great! I love the way Suzanne changes with each album.

I can't tell you how excited I am to listen to the whole album, hear how the lyrics are set to music, and of course, Suzanne's voice and her unique phrasing. Thanks again, Eric, for the wonderful job on the website: it's worth all the awards, and more.

Khairyl


Subj: Re: Lyrics from "Nine Objects Of Desire", firm release date, single
Date: 96-07-10 14:04:52 EDT
From: 74034.643@compuserve.com (Brian Rose)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@law.emory.edu (Undertow)

To David and others feeling trepidation concerning the impending release of Suzanne's new album:

Relax. It's a wonderful album both musically and lyrically. It may have been hard to write, but it sounds effortless. The album has atmosphere. There's no one big song, rather a groove that flows from song to song. This is an album people will listen to over and over. The songs are serious, but there's a lighter touch--a wryness that Suzanne has always had, but hasn't always been able to express musically. No attempt has been made to puff the songs up into big pop ballads. Caramel, which you've all heard, is a good example of this. Just when you expect the groove to build to a climax it holds back and the slender thread of melody and Latin rhythm remain unburdened. It's a gem as are each of the tracks on the album. I won't go on further about the other songs. Better to wait and hear them all together when the album is released.

Brian Rose


Subj: Re: Lyrics from "Nine Objects Of Desire"
Date: 96-07-10 15:22:36 EDT
From: rwalters@lafayette.unocal.com (Rob Walters)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@law.emory.edu

[ s n i p ]

The new songs, while they may be more 'immediate' or direct lyrically, still seem to me to have Suzanne's unmistakeable quality to get at the heart of an issue, whether it's a past love, as in "Headshots" (and what a unique way she leads in to that!) or a more immediate passion, as in "Caramel" or "Stockings." BTW - isn't Birthday a scary and yet slightly humourous description of the experience of a difficult birth? - "a needle here, needle there / tremble in the fog." All IMHO, of course.

As far as loving every bit of an artist's work, wasn't it our own Wendy! who said that if Suzanne put out an album of scratching noises, she would still listen? ;-)

-Rob


Subj: Some first impressions
Date: 96-09-09 10:35:09 EDT
From: algranti@club-internet.fr (David Algranti)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

I can't wait to tell you about some of my first impressions of the album, but I'll try not to reveal anything so I won't spoil your own first listening (anyway you're not forced to read this):

-The songs don't suffer at all from being too short, like in the previous album, except that I wish there were fewer open-ended songs.
-I think that 'No Cheap Thrill' is a pretty bad choice for a single and I'd be very surprised if it ever became a hit. They should have chosen 'Birth-day' (surprising song for Suzanne, it could have made a hit but maybe that it would have brought a kind of public she isn't looking after), 'Headshot' (which is awesome), 'Caramel' or 'World Before Columbus'. I can say that because this is precisely the kind of thing you can only see at the first listenings.
-Suzanne has really changed, this album is much happier than the others, 'Tombstone' is almost funny, the piano makes me think of saloon music, and the song reminds me a bit of 'Black Widow Station'
-'My Favorite Plum' is really sweet
-'Honeymoon Suite' is the most Suzanne-typical song

Well I can't tell you everythiong I like in the album because it would be too long, but here are some (light) disappointments:
-It's very... weird how she repeats "Oh Yeah" in 'Stockings', but maybe it means something in the song, I'll have to read the lyrics carefully
-I've now checked all the lyrics and it seems to me that 'World Before Columbus' has the kind of lyrics she has always avoided (but the music is great). Once again I haven't translated it and maybe I'll probably change my mind soon. But moreover, when she says 'It would be as flat as the world before Columbus', well... err... I don't know how to tell you this, Suzanne, but Columbus never proved the world was round. Copernic made the theory long before, and Magellan actually proved it after Colombus'death. I won't teach anyone anything if I say that Colombus thought the world was round and so wanted to reach India by the west, and he never did, so he didn't prove anything at all.
And when she says 'It would be as cruel as the world before Columbus', well I'm not sure that her (adoptive) Puerto-Rican roots that she tries to go back to with this album would agree, it could even make them mad.

well anyway this album is more than great and it's good to see that I wasn't wrong, that I really love everything she does. What's strange is that there's really a connection between her songs and me, like I thought. I mean I already feel like I've known all these new songs long before (though they're all very innovative), they already are a part of my life.

And I think that this album can be very successful in the UK because it's a strange blend of the two UK crazes of these days: trip-hop and easy-listening music (any English undertowers can confirm that?). I don't know if it's the same in the US and I wonder if Suzanne was aware of it, but a lot of things in the album (bossa-nova, things from the 40s, 50s and 60s (like she says), plus the artwork (that I have now checked on the web)) are really close to this easy-listening fashion.

David.


Subj: Re: Some first impressions
Date: 96-09-09 11:48:02 EDT
From: rwalters@lafayette.unocal.com (Rob Walters)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Hello everyone,

!!! WARNING - 'SPOILER' for those who haven't heard the album yet !!!

David wrote:
>-I think that 'No Cheap Thrill' is a pretty bad choice for a single and I'd
>be very surprised if it ever became a hit.

Really?? Why? To me, it was an obvious choice as a first single. Very straightforward, catchy chorus, and it's got a good melody (reviewers of previous albums always complained that melody wasn't her strong suit!).

>'Birth-day' (surprising song for Suzanne, it could have made a hit but maybe
>that it would have brought a kind of public she isn't looking after),
>'Headshot' (which is awesome), 'Caramel' or 'World Before Columbus'.

Birthday (Love Made Real) is indeed a bit of a departure, but it's not too much of stretch from Blood Makes Noise. What kind of fan is she looking *not* to attact? Caramel has already been released as a single, I think. OTOH, World Before Columbus is a little more laid back, takes a while to sneak up on you. Headshots I'll agree is a great song, and maybe this could be another single, but Suzanne's not really a 'singles' artist - the strength is in the concept of the album as a whole. I'd say they were *right on* w/ NCT as the 'first' single.

>-Suzanne has really changed, this album is much happier than the others,
>'Tombstone' is almost funny, the piano makes me think of saloon music, and
>the song reminds me a bit of 'Black Widow Station'

Agreed that her perspective is different now - more emotionally involved. Tombstone *is* kind of amusing, although the 'desire' in this case is for death and peace and quiet , so to speak - "there'll be no dancing on the gravestone, you must let me sleep", etc. I like the line "... but I do try to see the kingdom every now and then..." ;)

-'My Favorite Plum' is really sweet

Yes - it's just about perfect.

> I don't know how to tell you this, Suzanne,
>but Columbus never proved the world was round.

On WBC, I wouldn't take the simile ('flat as the world before Columbus') too literally. It's a convenient analogy she uses to make her point.

>well anyway this album is more than great and it's good to see that I wasn't
>wrong, that I really love everything she does.

A few tracks did nothing for me ('Lolita,' 'Thin Man'), but it's still a great album! The songs have such solid grooves and rhythms that match the lyrics and atmosphere so well that it *feels* spontaneous. No one can accuse her of being over-studied and too careful on this one. Brava, Suzanne!

-Rob


Subj: Hurricane Fran causes delurk
Date: 96-09-11 14:13:56 EDT
From: EBannan@mail.dot.state.nc.us (Eric Bannan)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Hello Suzanne and fellow undertowers.

I live in the Raleigh area in North Carolina. We are still reeling from the hurricane. I am on my 6th day without electricity at home. Good thing I have a CD player in my car.

Yesterday I braved flood waters, inoperative traffic signals etc. and made it to my local CD store to pick up Nine Objects Of Desire. I love it. Strange how some music critics equate latin influence with "lounge music". This may take the place as my favorite SV album. I'm not sure what my favorite cut is yet. I like Caramel and Headshots but Lolita, Birth-day and Tombstone are also in the running. Mitch Froom deserves a great deal of credit because the production is Incredible.

The website is really great. If you dig enough you can find SV's comments on just about every song she has recorded, and I never would have known one of my favorite songwriters is married to my favorite producer.

I am performing songwriter. I am curious how many other undertowers are musicians and/or songwriters.

E. E. Bannan


Subj: '9OOD' released Sept 6
Date: 96-09-12 08:53:40 EDT
From: juspuk@propus.tkk.utu.fi (Pukkila Jussi)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

About the new tracks: My favourite is 'Thin Man' which sounds a lot like Steely Dan to me. Throughout the album I get Twin Peaksy feelings, especially the break part after the chorus in 'Honeymoon Suite' and the last track, 'My Favorite Plum'.


jussi p
(that is my name :)

PS. I think that in one pic inside the leaflet Suzanne looks like Alanis Morissette.


Subj: Finally
Date: 96-09-13 02:02:45 EDT
From: djhamma@aloha.net (David J. Hammar)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

My NOOD CD arrived today! Just finished the first running, and loved it all, with one reservation--"No Cheap Thrill". Although I can perhaps see why it was selected as the first (post-release) single (It's a catchy tune, easily accessible, and doesn't make many mental demands on the listener), I also feel it's probably my least favourite track on the album. (Charges of blasphemy accepted here.)

Perhaps as SV fans we've been somewhat spoiled, but for me one of the most attractive facets of her songs are the mental imagery they evoke (at least for me) and the effort spent trying to grasp precisely what each song is about. For the most part, Suzanne never sings *about* something, rather she describes the effects the subject of her song has on the people and objects around it. (Just my personal observation -- I'm not a professional music critic, nor do I play one on TV...)

Listening to NCT failed to really inspire any deep thoughts or emotions. Instead, I found myself thinking that the somewhat bitter/cynical lyrics sounded quite out of character for the sweet voice singing them. It'd be really interesting to hear her sing this with a bit more of an edge, even a little sarcasm -- a vocal a bit more in the "rock" arena, perhaps.

Does anyone else see what I'm saying?

OK, I'll shut up now and go back to listening to the CD...
-- Dave H.
http://www.aloha.net/~djhamma


Subj: perspective and metaphors
Date: 96-09-13 04:03:28 EDT
From: algranti@club-internet.fr (David Algranti)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Hi, it seems I can't stop posting these days, but I can't wait for discussing the new lyrics.

I've noticed two major changes in Suzanne's lyrics on NOOD: no more perspective and much much more metaphors. When I say 'no more perspective' I don't mean that she's no longer keeping things in perspective (keeping her blood cold), I mean that all of her new songs are sung by 'I' and that this 'I' seems to actually be Suzanne herself, whereas in the past she might have BEEN the plum instead; in Birth-day she could have been the doctor or even MF... And no, she even loses her cold blood in 'Birth-day'. For me this song is like a little movie, where 'you' is MF or her mother or any close relative, or maybe the doctor. And this song begins like a march, towards like a huge celebration, because Ruby's coming out, and then she gets furious (with pain) and even threatens MF (or whoever 'you' is). That's the one song that I thought should have been open-ended. Anyway, just an interpretation.

And my theory about Suzanne's lyrics used to be that she used very few (if any) metaphors, she would just describe things as they were, and she would for instance give Solitude its own body, which is to me kind of the opposite of a metaphor. Now the ultimate desire - whatever it is - is represented as a plum (see the live-chat session transcript), who knows what 'caramel' and 'cinammon' mean, and death is a 'thin man'. Well I don't know if some would like to argue about this last one but for me it's obvious ('when I step down the sidewalk', 'when I walk down this dark halls', 'he's the thin man with the date for me... I don't know when it will be'): first I thought it was just a man but he reminded me of Mrs. Solitude so much because he seemed both always here and never really here. Then it just popped up to me (plus Suzanne said that death was the OOD in two songs; the first one being 'Tombstone' with no doubt). It must be a hell of a crowded place around Suzanne, with all those abstract feelings following her around.

I know that some of you said they didn't like hearing other people's interpretations of the songs, but for this album, Suzanne set the rules: two songs for Ruby ('Birth-day' and 'WBC' no doubt), one for Lolita, one for another girl ('Stockings'), one for a plum, two for death ('Tombstone' no doubt, and 'Thin Man' no doubt to me), two for MF ('Honeymoon Suite' obviously and IMHO 'No Cheap Thrill' but I'm not quite sure), and one for each of three other men ('Caramel' and 'Headshots' no doubt to me, and wether 'No Cheap Thrill' or 'Casual Match'). But I wouldn't be surprised if Suzanne has covered her tracks and if this was all bluff.

David.


Subj: 9OOD/WBC
Date: 96-09-13 10:21:43 EDT
From: Jeremy513@aol.com
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Okay, I'm late, finally bought the album, and pow: instantaneous connection. Call me impulsive, I've got no problems launching this one to the top of my list of her records. I feel as if the voice she sought on 99.9F has come to fruition. Let's leave alone considerations about musical labels and all, it seems more a question of finding a musical voice the way, say, a novelist has a voice. Not that she didn't have a voice before, but to my ears it became more tentative for a while there. I think that was one of the things that didn't sit completely right w/ me w/ DOOH (sorry again, Wendy!!); I didn't sense a...a what?...a confident voice? Maybe someone knows what I mean. 99.9F seemed a first reassertion; 9OOD exudes confidence, clarity, variety, intrigue, purpose. Awesome.

Two other points. I've opted for 9OOD (which at least one other person has already introduced) as a shortcut because, well, NOOD just keeps looking like we're always about to start talking about noodles. It's a problem when acronyms create or suggest words that have nothing to do w/ the thing being, um, acronymized.

Last and more important: I really sort of wanted to steer clear of the WBC debate but I thought we might all want to ponder what it says about our cultural times when someone with a clear, obvious, even striking record of compassion and intelligence can be questioned, can in fact feel herself somewhat under attack, based on an interpretation of one particular song. Please please please understand that I do not point particular fingers, I'm just saying it's food for thought for all of us to try to remember in our dealings with everyone, all the time, the idea of 'benefit of the doubt.' We live in jumpy times, I guess, and that seems to make everyone ready to jump on everyone else at the merest glimmer of a suspicion of a questionable attitude.

I feel badly that it took that sort of thing to prompt SV back onto the list. I sure hope she doesn't, as someone has suggested, now have second thoughts about the song. How sad that would be; it's a beautiful piece of work. I guess I should be more realistic in recognizing that if there are people out there who are going to misinterpret it, she may be in for a bit of discomfort, regardless of her intentions. But the idealist in me is saddened by that, I can't help it.

Well anyway, I hope I, in turn, have expressed myself w/out giving offense, because that is never my intention.

Happy listening, all..

Jeremy


Subj: Re: 9OOD
Date: 96-09-13 13:02:30 EDT
From: kubon@cs.sfu.ca (Petr Kubon)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Is there anybody out there who doesn't instantaneously like the album that much?! Just curious, I still haven't got my copy yet - but from past experience I know that my all-time favourite CDs grew on me over time, some of them I didn't even like the first time at all!

Pp


Subj: Re: 9OOD
Date: 96-09-13 14:33:42 EDT
From: Keith.Sawyer@FMR.Com (Sawyer, Keith)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu
CC: kubon@cs.sfu.ca (Petr Kubon)

Petr Kubon wrote:

>Is there anybody out there who doesn't instantaneously like
>the album that much?! Just curious, I still haven't got my
>copy yet - but from past experience I know that my all-time favourite
>CDs grew on me over time, some of them I didn't even like the
>first time at all!

I can completely sympathize - most of my all-time favorites took a three-month incubation period before revealing their brilliance.

Whenever I pick up a highly anticipated new release (like 9OOD) I try to savor it like a great meal. Right now I'm still in the process of just enjoying the musical sound/texture and Suzanne's splendid voice - I agree with Jeremy513 that it's the finest she's ever sounded. But I'm nowhere near the level of actually trying to figure out what the songs are *about* - because if I did I'd start devouring the release, and would soon be worn out after a month. No, I'm taking it slow here...

One thing that has jumped out at me from 9OOD is the fantastic drumming/drum loops. The hop and skip opening to Headshots (my early favorite) adds an enegry to the song beneath its languid exterior ... and the complexity of Casual Match brings out all sorts of temptation to break my initial "don't play the same song twice" rule. Kudos to all those responsible...

keith


Subj: Re: perspective and metaphors
Date: 96-09-13 18:50:31 EDT
From: BobandSooz@aol.com
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: algranti@club-internet.fr, undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

In a message dated 96-09-13 04:03:28 EDT, algranti@club-internet.fr (David Algranti) writes:

>> It must be a hell of a crowded place around Suzanne, with all those abstract feelings following her around. <<

How very funny! I bet she laughs really hard if she reads that. I bet it is true. I think she must never get bored wherever she goes, either, because she has an entire entertainment system inside her head, built in, of all those amazing ideas and images.

You mentioned metaphors -- but Suzanne has always used tons of metaphors and personification in her writing, because using figures of speech is a good way to take the big universal abstract themes of life (all the emotions, events, things common to man -- death, love, war, despair, exhilaration, annoyance at people who cut you off in traffic) and make them into personal and concrete images that listeners can carry around in their heads all day. "Solitude" doesn't put a picture in your head, because it is abstract, but "Solitude stands ..." -- that is something your brain can give form to. "If language were liquid..." Really, you could make pages and pages of lists of Suzanne Personification and Metaphors. (She seems to stay away from similes, which I think is cool, because they draw attention to the fact that the thing isn't what she is saying it is.)(I think "Today I am like a small blue thing" would have really blown it, don't you?)

"Death is a thin man" is probably what a lot of people picture, if they have to give an image to death. (Somebody who looks like Ichabod Crane or Mr. Burns on the Simpsons, or that little guy from Nightmare Before Christmas?)(I always think death is the Ghost of Christmas Yet-to-Come, from Dickens.)(What does anybody else see?)

I teach American Lit. in high school, and I use Suzanne's music in our poetry section to teach figures of speech, because she is such a solid writer, never a cliche, and the students seem to catch on really quickly because they are intrigued by her images. Me, too. I mean, I am intrigued by her images; I don't mean, they are intrigued by me. = )


Subj: First NOOD impressions and a quick de-lurk
Date: 96-09-14 14:44:12 EDT
From: FroggyJen@aol.com
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Hi Undertowers!

Oh me, I never post here. It's so bad of me. But last night I finally got out of my house -- the only time I've left in the past week is to go to school! yikes! -- for dinner with a friend, and after, since I had leftover money, we ran across the street to Barnes and Noble. My original plan was to buy Weetzie Bat, by Francesca Lia Block, but when they didn't have it, I decided to tease myself by looking at NOOD, even though I knew that I wouldn't be able to afford the $15 they'd charge for it. So I wandered to the music section, looked at the front table, and GASP! There was Suzanne with her redder-than-before hair and apple for only $11.99!! Much excitement...I found myself talking to her on the cover of the album. (Yes, I'm an idiot, but I'm also the girl who says hello and goodbye to the Tori Amos poster in the music store down the street :) .) So of course I bought it and herded my friend out of the store and home as fast as I could so I could *finally* listen to the album and read all of the letters I had from the list! (I didn't let myself read anything about NOOD because I didn't want to spoil the surprise.... Great idea, unless you've *got* to read the posts so you can get them organized and converted to HTML for the web page. We all know that *I'll* be doing today... ::grin::)

First impressions -- I *love* World Before Columbus. Wendy!, I love the way you described the song. Listening to it reminds me of when I was very small, and at night my parents would come in and sit on my bed, and the hall light would be on to give some light to my room, and my dad would bring his guitar in and sing me Peter Paul & Mary and Pete Seeger and Weaver's songs to put me to sleep.

No Cheap Thrill is another favorite...it makes me want to dance in my chair and conduct like I do with some of my favorite Tori songs. The only problem with this is that the chair is broken and makes squeaking noises that interfere with the song. Oh well... :)

I like the first four songs (I'm too lazy to type them out, but you know who they are :) a lot, too. This is just a great album. I doesn't give me the feeling that Solitude Standing did when I first got it, though...it's more of a Days Of Open Hand feeling for me. This is a good thing, of course...I *loved* DOOH when I got it.

I suppose I'll go back to my little corner now...
Goodbye friends.
Jen.
who is disappointed that (a) she missed Shawn Colvin when she was here, and (b) Suzanne won't be gracing Texas with her wondrous presence. Hello DFW folks! I'm one too!


Subj: Nine object of Desire.
Date: 96-09-19 00:47:47 EDT
From: janvier@odyssee.net (Guillaume Lesage)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

It took me some time to write to you all. It is because I was listening to NOOD for hours and hours. This is my forst letter in Undertow but I really enjoyed reading your comments thru the last two months.

I find her last album absolutely fantastic. And since she told me that the plum represents the acheivement, I thougt it was interesting to see the album in a satisfaction/unsatisfaction way. Birth-day could be a song of satisfaction (a painfull one) and My favorite Plum one of insatisfaction (it hangs so far from me). It is mad, I look at the lyrics and I find myself thinking that she could be talking of her career in this song. (... I've seen the rest (best), yes and that is the one for me) I know this may sound contradictive becaus of what I have wrote previously but in my heart, I know that I can (or my) be out of the track.

Guillaume Lesage (Fatman [it is not a joke, i'm really fat!!!])

janvier@odyssee.net


Subj: Yabadabadooooooooh
Date: 96-09-21 11:55:50 EDT
From: guida@mail.telepac.pt (Guida Fonseca)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu (Got caught by the Undertow)

OK !

I know that you all already have the 9OOD (well, except the ones in UK), but I would like to share the end of my anguish....I bought it today !! I was walking down the main street downtown, when I listen this angelical voice singing "I'll see you, I'll call you, I'll raise you, BUT IT'S NO CHEAP TRHILL..."

Finaly at sale on the stores, (I thought to my buttons)- next thought- only have the (equivalent value of my country's currency) 30 $ on my credit card - next step - run/flew up the stares from where the sound came, grabed the young boy who was at counter, gave him my credit card and asked the CD.

He sold me the CD, and just when I was leaving the store I remembered that I didn't ask for the price of it....

27$, he relyed ! I got it close enough...

When I steped down to the street again, I noticed that the friend who was with me, has certainly continued her way down the street. It wasn't, indeed, no cheap thrill, I'll have to appologise later....

World Before Columbus is the most beautifull song that I've heard and no words can described what I feel every time I listen it. I guess that the closest feeling is that of a work of art that just can't be framed, and the kind of love that I don't know, and so I take it as a gift of an emotion that I don't know.

I like "Stockings" for its hint and also for its question "Do you Know...?"

Honeymoon Suite, it's very amusing...I wouldn't like to be in Mitchell shoes !

The middle of Birth-day is very painfull (noisy), but I guess that's not as much as it was for Suzanne.

Bye all, I'll listen WBC again !
Guida.


Subj: Most Desirable "Objects"
Date: 96-09-22 02:27:48 EDT
From: arel@pc.jaring.my (Khairyl Yassin)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Dear fellow undertowers,

So, what do you guys think of the new album?

I think it's very good, although I wouldn't know at what rank as compared to her previous albums. Musically, I think it's more satisfying as a whole album than 99.9F, although it doesn't have the urgency of Blood Makes Noise or the charming quirkiness of Rock In This Pocket. Anyway, for me, "Suzanne Vega" still rules :).

I think the new direction that Suzanne is taking with her lyrics is interesting and brave. It's quite a challenge to write in a more direct, warmer way, while maintaining intelligence. As she said, it's less cerebral, and more emotional. I like the change, as I feel that it's important for artists to change, but I miss the complex, multi-layered approach of her previous works.

Here are my favorite "Objects":

1. World Before Columbus -- Touching, emotional, one the warmest songs that Vega has ever written. Absolutely gorgeous melody. I'm having the clamps, tawk amongst yourselves.

2. Thin Man -- Arguably one of the most sensual songs about death, if there was one. Cool, jazzy track recalls early Santana.

3. Caramel -- Aches with longing, it's Astrud Gilberto with bulimia. Fatalist, like most Brazilian music, and so romantic.

4. Headshots -- Groovy and spooky. Nice little segue at the end comparing the lost boy with a doomed relationship. But what's with that loud snare at the chorus?

5. My Favorite Plum -- Very Angelo Badalamenti. Nice soundtrack candidate for David Lynch's new movie "Lost Highway". Like Caramel, so doomed, yet so romantic.

Least favorites:

1. Lolita -- weak lyrics, weak rhythms. Better chorus, but not enough to save the pretty baby.

2. Tombstone -- here lies melody, rest in peace.

3. Stockings -- Great lyrics, bad music. That pseudo-Middle Eastern synth break is probably the cheesiest thing Suzanne has ever done.

That's my two cent's worth. Hope I didn't offend anybody :).

Take care,

Khairyl


Subj: Less Desirable "Objects"
Date: 96-09-23 17:54:53 EDT
From: rwalters@lafayette.unocal.com (Rob Walters)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Hello everyone,

Khairyl wrote:
>I think it's very good, although I wouldn't know at what rank as
>compared to her previous albums.

I'm going to have to give it a mixed review for now - the lyrics and subject matter, for the most part, do not hold up (for me) under repeated listenings. Up to this point, anyway.

> As she said, it's less
>cerebral, and more emotional. I like the change, as I feel that it's
>important for artists to change, but I miss the complex, multi-layered
>approach of her previous works.

Perhaps this is the problem I'm having with it. Maybe I should say: "I prefer the cerebral approach." Where is the clever wordplay of songs like "Knight Moves," the inventiveness of "Language," "Ironbound/Fancy Poultry," and "Small Blue Thing"? Not to mention the grand scope of "Big Space," "Pilgrimage" or many of the other songs from 'Days.' IMHO, the lyrics suffered from the 'confessional' approach and subject matter she chose for 9OD. And the lyrics are usually her strong suit.

>1. World Before Columbus -- Touching, emotional, one the warmest songs
>that Vega has ever written. Absolutely gorgeous melody.

Now this one I agree with. A very well done, well crafted, and touching love song.

>2. Thin Man -- Arguably one of the most sensual songs about death, if
>there was one. Cool, jazzy track recalls early Santana.

This one didn't do much for me. I prefer her treatment of the death figure in "Solitude Standing." I didn't care for the production on it.

>4. Headshots -- Groovy and spooky. Nice little segue at the end
>comparing the lost boy with a doomed relationship.

Yes, I agree - and the production (keyboards) didn't detract from it. I also like the way the doomed relationship ties in, much the same way as in "In Liverpool," one of my favorites from 99.9F.

>1. Lolita -- weak lyrics, weak rhythms. Better chorus, but not enough to
>save the pretty baby.

Agreed. The weakest track by far, and no melody to speak of.

>2. Tombstone -- here lies melody, rest in peace.

This I liked a bit better, and it is slightly humourous, in a morbid kind of way. However, the "time is burning" line weakens it, I think.

>3. Stockings -- Great lyrics, bad music. That pseudo-Middle Eastern
synth break is probably the cheesiest thing Suzanne has ever done.

Good lyrics, and yes, again, I think the production detracts. So, if anyone's still reading, I'll give (like the movie critics Siskel and Ebert) two thumbs up - way, way up - for WBC and Headshots, and a mixed review for the remainder of the album. Your mileage may vary, and like Khairyl, I hope no one is offended. I did try to preface my criticisms by saying "I prefer..." Who knows, maybe with time, more of 9OD will grow on me.

-Rob ;)


Subj: Re: Less Desirable "Objects"
Date: 96-09-23 20:17:17 EDT
From: s3033469@student.anu.edu.au (Robin Shortt)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Rob Walters wrote:

>Khairyl wrote:

>>1. Lolita -- weak lyrics, weak rhythms. Better chorus, but not enough to
>>save the pretty baby.
>
>Agreed. The weakest track by far, and no melody to speak of.

I basically put this one in the "Gypsy" pile ... a lot of people like that, but it doesn't do that much for me. I have similar feelings about "Honeymoon Suite", but a bunch of you like that, too, so ... I mean, Suzanne, while my favourite artist, bears absolutely no relation to anything else I listen to, so I guess I like different songs than those of you who dig Shawn Colvin et al.

>>3. Stockings -- Great lyrics, bad music. That pseudo-Middle Eastern
>synth break is probably the cheesiest thing Suzanne has ever done.
>
>Good lyrics, and yes, again, I think the production detracts.

Now this I would have to disagree with. I think that synth break recalls some of the best moments of 99.9F0 - also, it'd _rock_ live. Crank up that synth to around the 100dB mark and extend the break and you've got a great tune. I'm thinking here of "If You Were In My Move" in particular; the album version was solid, but the live version was _great_. (IMO, doing "Stockings" live as an acoustic song is the wrong way to go, but what do I know?)

> So, if
>anyone's still reading, I'll give (like the movie critics Siskel and
>Ebert) two thumbs up - way, way up - for WBC and Headshots, and a
>mixed review for the remainder of the album. Your mileage may vary,
>and like Khairyl, I hope no one is offended. I did try to preface my
>criticisms by saying "I prefer..." Who knows, maybe with time, more of
>9OD will grow on me.
>
>-Rob ;)

Okay guys, get Room 101 ready ...

Seriously, though, it's nice to know we're not a bunch of drones here, as long as we all remain level-headed ...

Cheers,
Robin


Subj: I'm speechless
Date: 96-09-27 02:26:40 EDT
From: bobking@gate.net (If you don't leave, I can't start)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Part 1

{ In which the protagonist
acquires three objects of artistic
merit, and discussion concerning
one of these ensues. }

It must be some kind of harmonic convergence: in one day, a new Suzanne Vega album, a new R.E.M. album, a new Joan Didion novel and a new job. In descending order of importance.

What can I say? The subject line says it all. Oh dear God, oh whatever or whoever is in heaven, if there's a heaven, wherever that is, if "where" means anything anymore, or Godess, or the universe, or the four directions or the stars or fate or yin and yang and all that stuff -- What An Album.

If 99.9F was her Sgt. Pepper, this is Abbey Road.

It may be her best. It's certainly much different from everything that came before. Stylistically it seems to most resemble Days, or at least Days if it had really excellent (as opposed to just good) production (it has all those wonderfully insane Froomish moments that Days lacked), or Days' thematic ambitions grafted onto 99.9's daring and skating-on-the-edge whimsy. With something else added, however.

Everyone's noted this already: she's writing from a much different place than she's written from before. And obviously that has much -- or everything -- to do with the changes she's gone through in the past four years, the plums she's pulled from the tree (her life's mate, her child), the fact that she's claimed her role as not only destination but also source in the cycle of life and death. What she's singing about now are, I would argue, NOT secrets learned from the edge of a knife, not just "romance and mental health," but lessons she's learned over years, through blood, through love, through time, through realization of how much she now has to lose. She's passed some ways along that pilgrimage she was singing about six years ago, with companions other than her old pal Solitude, and she's paused to offer us her reflections on what she's experienced.

Lucky us.

Can this be the woman who's so often been regarded as cold and aloof? Or fragile? The paragon of detatched observation? She's anything but that here. She's wise, and sexually frank, and teasing, and whistful, and fullblooded, and funny, and sorrowful. Wise especially. Her songwriting has always been mature (even that song to her kid brother she wrote when she was 12, or "The Silver Lady"), but this is a whole new dimension. Maybe she's just more confident about what she knows, as I imagine anyone would have to be after giving birth for the first time, but that's just my supposition. (Let's face it -- "Birth-day" is the one SV song that I will never be able to fully identify with, except only weakly by analogy.)

Let's discuss "Birth-day" for a second: Has _anyone_ ever written such an unsentimental song about childbirth? (How many childbirth songs are there, anyway?) Calling Ruby a "hot little treasure" -- just perfect. I love the linear structure of the song, the way it doesn't so much cycle as just plunge headlong through the experience, with Suzanne's freakouts growing in intensity.

"Headshots" -- the most immediately haunting song to me, the one I couldn't get out of my head when I first heard it. I can't figure out what its literal meaning is (why the sign said "headshots," who the boy is), and I'm not sure I want anyone to explain it to me. For some reason the song makes me think of Anton.

"Caramel" is just wonderful, which we've all known for months. Her voice is better than ever here.

TO BE CONTINUED

Part 2 { In which the tomato conundrum
is raised anew, modifiers
become an issue, and we are forced
to confront naked imperialism.
Also, Rush Limbaugh makes
a rare cameo appearance. }

"Stockings" could raise Wendy's tomato question anew (or I guess we could say that Suzanne is a plum), though I think speculation along those lines is both wrongheaded and cheapening to the song. I don't get the impression that this is intended to be a male narrator (I agree with whoever wrote that the "I" in all these songs appears to be Suzanne), although maybe it could be the flustered male from "99.9." Or maybe the woman in the stockings is Suzanne. But what I get from this song is what she's long made clear about herself, that she appreciates and recognizes the sexuality of women as well as men (Marlene Dietrich being the famous example), and one could well imagine a situation in which she could begin to wonder whether another woman was trying to turn her on. Or whatever. That she can write a song like this says a lot, I think. (It was funny that she said MF asked her, "Should I know something?"). She just comes off to me as complex, very human, and comfortable with ambiguity.

And, uh, could this have a few more entendres attached to it: "When she does not show you the way out on the way in"?

"Casual Match" has one slight flaw, in that I think it demonstrates how modifiers (like "very") can weaken the words they modify. "Very dry field" is just, by Vegan standards, not all that precise and evocative. "Dry field" would have been better, though of course it wouldn't have fit the line, but I can't think of too many SV songs that have words tossed in just to make the meter work. (No, I can't suggest an alternative. I certainly can't improve on Suzanne's work!) OTOH, the term "casual match" is, well, brilliant, capturing that double meaning of coupling and conflagration.

I think this song comes the closest to the old SV stance of detatched scrutiny, though in this case she's inviting _us_ to coolly observe the change in her emotions: "Observe the moment/when the heat of love becomes the chill of doubt." In this and her other "old flame" songs, I sense a definite stance of looking back to the pain of the past from the present where she's found her place in life and can put it all in perspective -- not erasing the pain, but being able to appreciate it from the long view. In this case it's like, "I've got a grip on my emotions and know what I'm feeling -- let's see how YOU like it.''

"Thin Man" -- I think David's hit it right on the money in id'ing this thin man as death. (The giveaway lines are in the chorus, especially "I don't know when it will be.") Someone in the chat commented on how "terrible" it was for Suzanne to bring up death while thinking of Ruby's birth, but what I find striking about the whole album is how everything in life seems to fall into its place in the whole cycle.

Given Suzanne's fondness for old movies, the "Thin Man" reference is especially amusing.

The melody on this one is a little hard to get into, though. The whole album has that sort-of-difficult-to-love-at-first quality that Days had, at least to me (99.9F and SV were immediate grabbers), but it grows and grows and grows with each listen. By listen #3 I was hooked.

"No Cheap Thrill": someone here didn't like the harsh tone of the narrator, but it reminds me of something that Suzanne might imagine Marlene Dietrich saying. And those entendres strike again ("I've seen what he's got and it isn't a lot"). The melody is just gorgeous, especially in the chorus. I agree this was the obvious single, and I find it odd I haven't heard it on the radio down here yet. (Actually, not too odd, since I haven't spent much time listening to the radio stations that would probably play this song. I don't want to have to sit through 12 Alannis Morissette and Hootie songs just to hear one by Suzanne.)

"World Before Columbus": I'm going to get pissed off if this interpretation business gets out of hand -- not at anyone here, since we all have the right to ask questions, but at anyone *out there* who would try to cry racism about a song they haven't bothered listening to. Without waxing William Bennett-ish, probably nobody would give the song a second glance if Suzanne had chosen a Buddhist or Hindu or Native American cosmological myth to build her song around, rather than picking a well-known medieval European superstition. Why is one more legitimate as song-fodder than the other?

And I was frankly baffled by the question about what Suzanne's Puerto Rican stepfather would think. Is someone under the impression that Hispanics were indigenous to the Americas? Who do you think was on the boat with Columbus?

The question ought to be settled by the chorus; it refers to the folly of everyone who chases after material riches, but I can't help seeing it couched in terms of the conquistadors:

Those men who lust for land And for riches strange and new Who love those trinkets of desire Oh they never will have you.

The chorus may be the most beautiful and heartbreaking thing she's ever written. Let's not see it ruined by the liberal equivalent of those Bible Belters who spend their time playing Motley Crue and Sheryl Crow records backwards to look for satanic messages.

(Actually, I sort of see this nightmare scenario: the PC crowd takes up the anti-WBC crusade, a la what the Cure went through with "Killing an Arab," prompting a backlash in which Rush Limbaugh starts playing the song on his show, proclaims his longtime admiration for Suzanne and invites her on the air. Of course, she could turn that to her advantage by proclaiming her support for gay marriages ... and, well, we'd have a lot of phone lines lighting up in ditto-land. Then Suzanne would have enough fans that she could play in Florida, except Eric and I wouldn't be able to get tickets because Limbaugh listeners would buy them all first. We could scalp tickets but only if we promised to assassinate Al Franken. And so it goes.)

Anyway, it's a good thing she didn't go with her original title, "The World Before Heinrich Himmler."

TO BE CONTINUED

Part 3

{ One thing we know: This
album must go. Final
thoughts on Lolita, ghosts,
death and that
unattainable Plum. }

"Lolita" -- musically, this strikes me as somewhat off-putting. Maybe it needs to grow on me. But thematically, it's fascinating. I see Suzanne as a maternal figure here, trying to steer the young Lolita from Bad Wisdom and offering her hard-won experience as a guide. "Hey girl, I've been where you are standing/leaning in the doorway in your mother's black dress." (Looking at the photos inside the booklet you can tell that SV's not a child, she's no longer a waif -- she's a grown woman, and apparently quite happy about it. Our society scorns age and experience; if you're in your 30s you're supposed to look 20s, etc. She seems to want no part of that. It's also striking how Latina she looks in the outside cover art.)

"Honeymoon Suite" is definitely not what I had anticipated, certainly the strangest honeymoon song I can think of. (It reminds me somewhat of that "Pension Grillparzer" story in _The World According to Garp_, though I'm sure that's just me.) This odd song suggests so much without her having to say it: The reference to "my husband," which is unusual in popular music (which is generally filled with juvenile romance or just-plain-impulsive sex, with many fewer references to husbands and wives and other committed relationships); yet, this being the honeymoon, you can imagine how new it must be, and what it must mean, for her to be able to say "my husband." The lines "we sleep so close together/that our hair becomes entwined" suggests intimacy and how long they've been together, yet the last two lines ("I must have missed that moment/in the gateway to his mind") add an element of doubt about much she still doesn't know about her new mate, how much distance can never be crossed between two people. And there she ends it. Draw your own conclusions.

"Tombstone" -- I think the description of "saloon-type" music fits this best. I had thought of it as kind of ragtimey, but that's probably wrong. MF's production is at its best here; I love the antiquey feel, the chatter at the beginning and the way it starts off in mono in one channel. The words speak for themselves. Suzanne just seems to happy (maybe content is a better word) that even death -- at least her own _ is just another part of the natural order.

"My Favorite Plum" is, to me, the standout on the whole album, the one that ties all this together. A lesser mind would have been content with the birth-death cycle as a theme, maybe even presented the songs in that order (ugh! concept album alert!), but she doesn't do that. I see this song as the coda, after the final death song, the reminder that life and demise continue but as long as she's here she still has something more that she desires. (And, as she put it during the chat, the end of all desire is death -- a phrase that strikes me as having at least three possible meanings. Leave it to Suzanne to be enigmatic even during an Internet chat session.)

The technique here seems to be the opposite of "Small Blue Thing" -- rather than picture herself as an object, she tells us about her own state of the mind by investing this plum with all sorts of imagined qualities: "See how it sleeps/ and hear how it calls to me./ See how the flesh/ presses the skin,/ It must be bursting/ with secrets within."

The whole album is a near-perfect marriage (in a couple senses, huh) of lyrics, music and production, but especially in this song, which has just plopped down into a craw of my consciousness and refuses to leave. It also strikes me as indescribably sad, since there always seems to be that one final plum, the one you can never have, the one that "would make my heart complete," and sometimes after waiting a long while beneath the tree you have to leave and go chase other plums in other trees, leaving that one still hanging there, never really knowing whether another shake of the bough would have done the trick. Maybe Suzanne's really stubborn about not leaving that tree (this woman who went to audition after audition as a teenager, always getting turned down but never giving up, performing in malls under dangerous electric wiring, all this until she achieved her goal), but even she's had to leave her share, I know. We all do, on certain days. And one such day is the day I finally bought this album and heard this song, which is what I will always think about when I listen to this album. And if there's one thing I think I know about the future it's that when it finally, whenever that is, comes my time to die (more time being the final, unreachable plum), this is the song I'll hear cycling around and around in my head until the end. Thanks, I guess.

For the whole album: Thank you, Suzanne. I'd say more, but as you can see you've struck me speechless.

-- Bob

"one thing I know
this day will go."
-- Suzanne

"Now I don't need a heaven,
I don't need religion,
I am in the place where I should be.
I am breathing water.
I am breathing water.
You know everybody's got to breathe."
-- R.E.M., "Undertow"

"History's rough draft.
We used to say.
When we still believed that history merited a second look."
-- Joan Didion, _The Last Thing He Wanted_

"Then she laid his head on her shoulder with her eyes fixed on the rose. The senator held her about the waist, sank his face into woods-animal armpit, and gave in to terror. Six months and eleven days later he would die in that same position, debased and repudiated because of the public scandal with Laura Farina and weeping with rage at dying without her."
-- Gabriel Garcia Marquez


Subj: Re: I'm speechless (Part 3)
Date: 96-10-02 10:55:11 EDT
From: rwalters@lafayette.unocal.com (Rob Walters)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu, bobking@gate.net

Hello everyone,

The inimitable Bob King wrote (on Fri.):

"Lolita" -- musically, this strikes me as somewhat off-putting. Maybe it needs to grow on me. But thematically, it's fascinating. (snip)
>"Hey girl, I've been where you are standing/leaning in the
>doorway in your mother's black dress."

I agree with you that musically, this song is hard to embrace. The one-note organ repeat is too reminiscent of Santana for me to block it out. But, don't you think that a song like "Neighborhood Girls" paints a picture that has much more impact? Instead of the direct "don't be like that" approach, it concludes with the lines "'I just wonder where she's gone?' Oh, she's gone? 'Yes, she's gone...'" This could have a more casually sinister interpretation - i.e. "what happened to her?" It's left for us to wonder. Or, "I didn't even notice she wasn't around anymore - oh well...." I didn't get that much out of "Lolita."

Re: "My Favorite Plum":
>The technique here seems to be the opposite of "Small Blue Thing" --
>rather than picture herself as an object, she tells us about her own
>state of the mind by investing this plum with all sorts of imagined
>qualities: (snip)

The narrator in "Small Blue Thing" also reveals much about her/his state of mind, but in different ways, i.e. "I am lost (against your pocket, against your fingers...)," "thrown against the sky," "in pieces," "falling," "scattering." These all suggest displacement of one kind or another, perhaps in both the physical and mental states. I'm not saying that MFP or SBT is 'better,' I'm just trying to point out the fact that although the narrator in SBT is comparing herself to an object, the object is still invested with qualities that relate back to her state of mind.

>The whole album is a near-perfect marriage (in a couple senses, huh)
>of lyrics, music and production,

I don't share your assessment completely, but thanks for a great review that made me think about some of 9OD in a different light.
-Rob


Subj: My opinions
Date: 96-10-02 18:20:53 EDT
From: coop@ctol.net (John Cooperider)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Well, I have been listening to Nine non stop since I got a CD that would open ;) As I listen to some of the songs I keep thinking of the musical similarities I hear. Please understand that these opinions are entirely my own. This is how I listen to music, you see.

"Casual Match" sounds dead on like a Talking Heads song to me. I can just hear David Byrne singing this one.

"Lolita" has a sound reminiscent of the Police (in my opinion) The percussion in the beginning sounds VERY similar to "Walking in your Footsteps" from Syncronicity

"My Favorite Plum" has a sound and feel that reminds me alot of Portishead. Not quite as depressing though... :)

And for those who are still reading, my favorite songs on the CD are Birth-day, WBC, and Stockings, but these are bound to change as I listen. My least favorites are the ones with music by Mitchell (Hmmm, sorry Mitchell, they are starting to grow on me.), but I really like the whole album. The concert this month will probably affect these picks. My favorite CD is still Days of Open Hand...for now.

John


Subj: Nine Objects of Desire
Date: 96-10-10 20:15:51 EDT
From: bll22536@infolink.net.il (Yehu Moran)
Sender: owner-undertow@law.emory.edu
To: undertow@serv4.law.emory.edu

Hello Everyone....
Well i got the Disc 2 weeks ago and i must say I LOVE IT!!!!!!! well when september arrived i was sure that the disc won't be released here (israel) at the 10th so i asked my from my Grandpa (he's a pilot) to buy it for me when He will be in New York....well i asked for 9OOD of Suzanne VEGA and my grandpa mistakenly bought me a CD game of SEGA....well it didn't made me too happy you know, but then i discovered the fact that the 9OOD was released here on the 10th....yes i know i am an idiot......
So i bought it two weeks ago and i listend to it again and again and i really love it.it's a very differnet Album.. almost no regular folk in it.But as usuall Suzanne experiments many different styles of music (I recognize some Blues and Jazz in some of the tracks) and the final result is GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!
I especially like Headshots and World Before Columbus. Headshots is a great song a very sad and very beutiful song.The Historic errors (that David A. mentioned) in WBC are completely unimportant.WBC is a very beutiful song and besides "World before Magellan" sounds pretty bad in Compare to "World Before Columbus" ;).yesterday i listebed to it 4 times in a row.yep i just love this song.
Birth-day reminds me Blood makes noise....it's a very powerful song..... It describes a powerful action in a very powerful way.the line "i wait to meet my love made real" in this context is really great!!! Caramel is a great. when it was released in the "the truth about cats and dogs" soundtrack i went to the local CD store and listened to it about 7 or 8 time in a row untill the owner gently asked me to buy it to go away.
Tombstone is a strange song.It's talking about Death in a very calm and cheerful way.Although i am not comfortable with this description i love the song.Yuval Gabay (an Israeli Drummer!) makes some really good job in this track for my opinion.
I must admit that No Cheap Trill is my least favorite song in the new album....but when i say about one of Suzanne's songs that's it's my least favorite i mean it's good but no great!
Nine Objects Of Desire is a great disc and it is good as Suzanne's previous albums.
I hope you enjoy it as much as i do and i envy all those of you in the U.S and Europe (i think that selection of songs in the Hamburg concert was great!!!) that will be able to see her soon in live concerts.....
Yehu :)

Please send your comments, suggestions, submissions to: VegaNet

Up to The Suzanne Vega Home Page

VegaNet@aol.com